@Michael G This is an incredible review and might I say I feel you have been way too kind about the short comings of the printer vs the promises during the campaign.
However I do feel you have covered everything about this printer.
This is my own personal review of the product so here is me throwing my two cents in.
Just to give some background I hold a Masters Degree in Mechanical Engineering and have work the oil and gas industry since graduating many years ago.
The Campaign
This was my very first 3D printer and I too was encouraged into backing this printer due to the alure and promise of a good dual extrusion set up, as well as the amazing prints that were shown in the campaign videos. Another bonus I thought the overall look of the printer was far more appealing then other budget printers on the market. I also did do my own research into printers and knew the drawbacks of single support gantry printers but proceeded due to the previously mentioned reasons.
The Assembly
The construction and programming/flashing of the printer was fine, the tutorials online documented the steps perfectly.
I too was missing a fixed linear guide and instead had a 3rd variable guide. I was also missing the second spool holder that was needed to mount and hold the second filament spool and stepper motor needed for the dual print system.
I didn’t have the time and was unwilling to wait (I was that excited about the printer at the time and wanted to get printing) for the replacements to arrive so I extended the cables myself using cables I had (as I fly freestyle drones and I have plenty of spare suitable wiring). I would like to add all the replacements did arrive in the end.
So once it was up and running and started printing the real problems started. To quickly summarise the problems of the poor and failed prints is down to this.
· Poor design of the linear guides
· Poor quality checks performed on the main printing bed and gantry assembly these weren’t level at all or within any acceptable fabrication tolerances for parts these sizes.
· I know this is a budget printer but poor quality cheap 3rd party parts the main one being the promised all metal hotend which is fact is a cheap e3d clone with a PTFE liner all the way through to the nozzle and not all metal.
· Badly compiled custom version of the cura program which was the main reason for the failure of the dual filament prints. I have uninstalled this now and am running cura 4.7.
· Serious lack of response from Makertech regarding issues since everything was delivered. They have just buried their heads in the sand with all the issues they clearly must have seen in this forum.
The Verdict
My overall verdict of this printer is to stay way clear of it. In the true spirit of 3D printing yes all these problems can be overcome but the fact you have to overcome them first before even getting an ok print is just a waste of time and money especially as there are plenty of printers at similar price to this with the cost of the extra’s (LCD, Hotplate and flexpate) that you NEED on the market that will provide decent prints with minimal head scratching involved.
Also if your new and on a budget this has the potential to really put people off this fun, educational and very rewarding hobby.
Its not been all bad, during the kickstarter campaign and up to it was delivered Makertech were good. After that, it has all gone downhill. I think its only saving grace is it was delivered during covid-19 and lockdown as it has given me something to focus on and tinker with.